Roof damage claims turn on one question: storm or age?

Start here

Why roof damage insurance claims are disputed more than any other part of the house

A roof is the one part of a building that is damaged by storms and worn out by weather at the same time, and the policy pays for the first and excludes the second.

Every property policy I read draws that line. Sudden, accidental damage from a covered peril — wind, hail, a falling tree, fire — is covered. Wear and tear, deterioration, and defects in how the roof was built or installed are excluded. On a roof that is fifteen years old and was hit by a storm last month, both are present on the same slopes, and the claim is decided by which one the inspection attributes the damage to.

That is why a roof claim is an inspection problem before it is a money problem. If the file cannot show that specific damage came from a specific event, the estimate never gets read. I work these roofs as a licensed roofing contractor in Illinois and as a HAAG certified inspector, so the same visit tells me what broke, what caused it, and what the repair actually costs.

If you already know the cause, the loss-specific pages go further: hail damage claims cover test squares and soft-metal evidence, and wind damage claims cover creased shingles and the opening that interior water depends on. This page is about what every roof claim has in common.

Roof age: what it changes and what it does not

The age of a roof comes up in almost every roof claim, and owners often hear it as a verdict. It is not one. Age affects three separate things, and it is worth keeping them apart.

The first row is the one owners most often get wrong in the carrier's favour. A twenty-year-old roof that took wind damage has a covered wind claim. What changes is the evidence standard: on an old roof, granule loss, curled tabs and brittle shingles are all present anyway, so the storm damage has to be distinguished from them rather than simply pointed at.

The third row is where age costs real money. A policy that settles on replacement cost pays the depreciation back once the work is done. A policy that settles the roof on actual cash value, or that carries a roof payment schedule scaling payment down by the age of the covering, does not. That wording is usually added at renewal and rarely noticed — it is worth reading in your own documents before deciding whether an offer is fair.

The wear-and-tear exclusion, and how storm damage is told apart from it

Wear is not a vague word on a roof. It has physical signs, and so does storm damage, and a competent inspection records which is which rather than calling the whole roof one or the other.

Wear shows up evenly. Granule loss spread across every slope, tabs curling at the edges, cracking along the surface of old shingles, exposed nail heads, sealant drying out around the pipe boots. It appears on the sheltered slope as much as on the exposed one, because time does not come from a direction.

Storm damage shows up in a pattern. Hail leaves impacts concentrated on the slopes facing the storm and corroborated by dents in the gutters and vents. Wind leaves creased tabs and broken seals banded along the edges, rakes and ridge on the windward side. Both line up with a date that the National Weather Service storm reports can confirm, and both usually leave evidence on the rest of the property that an old roof alone never produces.

When a denial letter says wear and tear, the useful response is not an argument about the word. It is a question about the record: which slopes were walked, what was found on each, and whether the pattern was compared against the storm direction. A denial that rests on a general description of an old roof can often be reinspected on the specific evidence.

Leaks: when a roof leak is a claim and when it is maintenance

A leak is the reason most owners first call anyone, and it is the weakest place to start a claim, because a policy does not pay for leaks. It pays for damage caused by a covered event, and a leak is only a symptom.

The same stained ceiling can sit on either side of that line. Water that came in through shingles a storm tore off or fractured follows a covered cause. Water that came in through a pipe boot that cracked over ten summers, a flashing that pulled loose slowly, or a valley worn through by age follows a maintenance cause, and the carrier will say so. The interior damage usually rises or falls with the answer on the roof above it.

Two Chicago-specific situations deserve a separate look. Ice dams in winter force meltwater back under the shingles, and a homeowner policy usually pays for some of what that does inside and excludes other parts of it — I wrote a guide on what a policy covers for ice dams. And a leak that has run for months before anyone noticed it is often limited by the policy's language on continuous or repeated seepage, which is a reason to report water promptly rather than watch the stain.

What a first roof inspection tends to miss

When a roof claim is accepted, the next disagreement is the scope — and a first estimate written from the ground, or from a quick walk, reliably leaves out the parts of a roof you cannot see from the ground. These are the lines I check on every carrier estimate I review:

• Decking. Soft, delaminated or rotted sheathing only appears once the shingles are off. An estimate that allows no decking at all is assuming something nobody has checked; the usual answer is a written allowance for replacement as found.
• Additional layers. A roof with two layers of shingles costs more to tear off and dispose of. If the layer count is not in the estimate, it was probably not looked at.
• Underlayment, ice barrier, drip edge and starter. Items the manufacturer's installation instructions or the local building code require on a new roof are part of the cost of replacing it, not an upgrade. Where code requires them, ordinance and law coverage may be what pays for them.
• Flashing, vents and pipe boots. Step flashing, counter flashing, ridge vents and boots are usually replaced with the roof rather than reused. They are among the most commonly missing lines on a first estimate.
• Steep and high charges. A roof above a certain pitch, or more than one storey up, takes more labour and more safety equipment. Both are standard estimate lines and both are frequently absent.
• Overhead and profit. A roof replacement usually involves more than one trade — gutters, siding, interior repairs — and a general contractor coordinating them. My guide on why O&P goes missing from roof estimates covers when it is owed.

None of these is exotic. They are ordinary parts of a roof replacement, and each is either in the estimate or it is money the owner pays out of pocket.

Repair or replacement: how the scope is argued

Carriers frequently approve a repair — a number of shingles, a section, one slope — where the owner expected a new roof. Whether a repair is actually possible is a construction question, and it has three practical parts.

How much of each slope is damaged. Damage counted and photographed across a slope supports its replacement; a handful of isolated marks supports a repair. This is why the inspection record matters more than the photographs of the worst spot.

Whether the roof can be repaired without damaging it further. Old asphalt shingles become brittle. Lifting a course to slide in a replacement can crack the shingles around it, and a repair that breaks more than it fixes is not a repair. A brittleness test, done and photographed on the roof, is evidence for that argument.

Whether a matching material exists. Shingle lines are discontinued and colours drift between batches. A repair that visibly does not match the rest of the roof raises the matching question, which I cover in a separate guide on when undamaged shingles and siding get replaced too.

What to do when you think your roof is damaged

1. 1

   Note the date of the storm

   A roof claim is tied to a specific event. If you are unsure of the day, National Weather Service storm reports are published by county and date and will usually settle it.

2. 2

   Photograph what you can see from the ground

   Missing shingles, debris in the yard, dented gutters and vents, water stains inside. Wide shots first, so each photograph shows which side of the house it is.

   Stay off the roof — let someone trained walk it
3. 3

   Protect the house and keep the receipts

   A tarp over an opening is a reasonable step your policy expects, and the cost is normally reimbursable. Photograph the damage before it is covered.

4. 4

   Ask for your complete policy in writing

   Every endorsement, not only the declarations page. Whether the roof is paid at replacement cost, actual cash value or on a payment schedule is written in there, and it changes what a fair offer looks like.

   Request it by email so the date is recorded
5. 5

   Do not sign a repair contract before the scope is settled

   A contract signed on the day of the storm fixes the price and the scope before anyone has read the carrier's estimate. Get the inspection first.

How I work a roof claim

I walk the roof myself, every slope, and record what I find on each one separately — storm damage where it is, wear where it is, and the pattern that tells them apart. As a licensed roofing contractor I also check what the roof is built from: the number of layers, the condition of the decking where it can be assessed, the flashing, the ventilation, and whether the existing shingle can still be bought. That turns into one file that answers both questions a carrier asks — what caused this, and what does it cost to put right.

Before discussing any number I read your policy in full, endorsements included, because a roof payment schedule or an actual-cash-value roof settlement changes the strategy of the whole claim. The estimate is priced at contractor-level cost with the tear-off, the layers, the decking allowance, the code-required items and the accessories that cannot be reused written in, rather than left for a supplement nobody files.

I file the claim, meet the insurer's adjuster on the roof, and work through the disagreement line by line. If the claim has already been denied as wear and tear, the ordinary next step is a reinspection built on a properly documented record — a denial is a conclusion drawn from an inspection, and an inspection can be done again.

The consultation and the inspection cost nothing. If I get on your roof and find it is simply old and the carrier read it correctly, I will tell you that plainly — it saves you a claim that would not succeed. You can see the full range of claim services, read my background as a roofer and adjuster, or book the free inspection whenever you are ready.

Volodymyr Lukaniuk is a public adjuster licensed in Illinois (No. 19461872) and Indiana (No. 3556317), a licensed Illinois roofing contractor (No. 105.009193) and a HAAG certified inspector (No. 992104047). A public adjuster represents policyholders on insurance claims and is not an attorney. Policy wording varies between insurers — the descriptions here are general and your own policy governs your claim. Nothing here promises a claim outcome, and no adjuster-client relationship exists until a written contract is signed.