Business income claims: the money a closed shop, restaurant or office loses while it's repaired

I'm Volodymyr Lukaniuk, a licensed public adjuster in Illinois and Indiana and a licensed roofer and general contractor. When a fire, a burst pipe or a storm shuts a shop, a restaurant or an office, the building is only half of the claim. The other half is the money that stops coming in, and the money you spend to keep going.

That half is paid for a set period, and the length of the period comes from how long the repair should take. I write that repair schedule myself, trade by trade, because every week in it is a week of income.

Closed for repairs
  1. Hour 0The fire, the pipe or the storm. Extra expense starts counting right away.
  2. Hour 72Lost business income starts counting.
  3. The day the repair should be doneMeasured at reasonable speed and similar quality, not the day it really ends.
  4. Up to 60 days after you reopenExtended business income, while sales climb back.

The clock in your policy, drawn on one line

On the standard commercial form, four coverages run on their own clocks. They start at different hours and stop on different days, so a claim that treats them as one period loses money at both ends.

Extra expenseFrom the hour of the loss to the day the repair should be done
From the hour of the loss
Business incomeFrom hour 72 to the day the repair should be done
Period of restoration
Extended business incomeFrom reopening, for up to 60 days
After reopening
Civil authorityFrom 72 hours after the order, for up to 4 weeks
Up to 4 weeks

The period of restoration ends on the date the property should be repaired, rebuilt or replaced with reasonable speed and similar quality. That's a schedule someone has to write. If the insurer writes it alone, it's usually short.

It also ends when business resumes at a new permanent location. If you sign a lease elsewhere for good, tell me first, because the clock stops on that day.

The expiration date of the policy doesn't cut the period short. A loss in the last month of the policy year is still counted to the end of the repair.

What the form counts as business income, and the papers that prove it

The form defines business income as the net income you would have earned, plus the normal operating expenses that keep running while you're closed, payroll included. Rent on a lease you still pay, loan payments and the salaries of people you keep on are all in it.

The amount is worked out from four sources the form names. The insurer's accountant will ask for each of them, so I gather them from your books, with your accountant, before the first meeting.

If you rent out space rather than run a business in it, the lost rent is counted a little differently: my page on two-flat and rental building claims covers that side.

Hands over an insurance policy form on a clipboard, with a pen pointing at a line of the form
Loss Determination, C.3.aWhat I ask you for
1

Net income before the loss

What the business really earned in the months before the damage.

Monthly profit and loss statements for the last two years, and the last two tax returns.
2

Likely net income without the loss

Where the business was heading. A busy season that was about to start, a new contract, a second chef hired in spring.

Sales by month, signed contracts, bookings, catering orders. The form leaves out any rise in sales caused by the disaster itself.
3

Expenses to reopen with the same quality of service

Payroll and the other costs needed to open at the level you were at the day before.

Payroll registers, leases, loan statements, service contracts.
4

Other records

The form names your financial records and accounting procedures, bills and invoices, and deeds, liens or contracts.

Whatever your accountant already keeps. I don't need anything made new for the claim.

Money you spend in the first week to keep the doors open

Extra expense pays costs you wouldn't have had without the damage. It starts the hour of the loss, without the 72-hour wait, and owners often pay these from their own account and never claim them. Keep every receipt from the first day.

To avoid or shorten the closure

The form pays these to keep operating at your premises, at a replacement premises or at a temporary location.

  • Moving stock and equipment to a temporary space
  • Rent for the temporary space, and the cost to equip and run it
  • Renting a generator, a cooler or a truck
  • Overtime to catch up on orders
  • Notices to customers about the new address

To repair or replace property

Here the rule is narrower. It's paid only to the extent it lowers the loss that would otherwise be paid.

  • Paying extra for a rush repair that opens you two weeks sooner
  • Buying a used oven now instead of waiting months for the new one
  • A temporary sign or storefront while the real one is made

The building repair itself is the property part of the claim. My page on commercial property claims covers how I scope it by trade, and the two parts share one repair schedule.

Damaged Shop A inside the mile Shop B outside 1 mile

When the street is closed and your shop isn't damaged

A fire next door, a facade coming down on the block, a gas leak across the street. The city closes the area and your business can't open, even though nothing of yours is broken. The standard form calls this civil authority.

It pays when covered damage to other property leads the civil authority to prohibit access to the area around it, your premises are inside that area, and they are no more than one mile from the damaged property. The order also has to come because of dangerous conditions from the damage, or to give the authority free access to it.

Income is counted from 72 hours after the first order, for up to four consecutive weeks. Extra expense starts right away. I keep a copy of the order, the barricade photos and the date the street opened again.

Within 1 mileStarts 72 hours after the orderUp to 4 weeks

Coinsurance, worked through with the numbers printed in the form

Many business income policies carry a coinsurance percentage on the declarations page. If the limit you bought is lower than that percentage of a year's net income and operating expenses, every loss is paid in the same proportion. The form prints its own example, and it's the clearest way to see it.

Step 1: the limit you should carry$400,000 x 50%

A year's net income and operating expenses, times the coinsurance percentage, gives $200,000.

Step 2: the limit you carry$150,000 / $200,000

The limit on the declarations, divided by the step 1 figure, gives .75.

Step 3: the loss$80,000 x .75

The amount of the loss, times .75.

What the form pays$60,000

The other $20,000 isn't covered. With a $200,000 limit, the same loss would be paid in full.

Example 1 under Section D, Coinsurance, of the ISO form CP 00 30 10 12, Business Income (and Extra Expense) Coverage Form. The year counted is the 12 months after the policy started or last renewed, not the year before the loss. Coinsurance doesn't apply to extra expense. Your policy may use another edition, a businessowners form or an insurer's own wording, so I read yours before I run any figure.

Three lines in the form that make a claim shorter

None of them is unusual, and each one has cost owners weeks of income because nobody pointed it out early.

Reopen as soon as you can

If you intend to continue your business, you must resume all or part of your "operations" as quickly as possible.

If part of the business can run, from the undamaged half of the building or from another address, the form reduces the income loss by what you could earn there. If you don't reopen, it pays on the time it would have taken. So I write down what was possible each week, and why the rest wasn't.

Delays from codes and permits aren't counted

"Period of restoration" does not include any increased period required due to the enforcement of or compliance with any ordinance or law...

Weeks spent waiting on a code upgrade fall outside the standard period. Some policies add an endorsement for this. I check your declarations for it, and I plan the permit work into the schedule from the first week, not after the inspector asks.

A sworn proof of loss on request

Send us a signed, sworn proof of loss containing the information we request to investigate the claim. You must do this within 60 days after our request.

The 60 days run from the insurer's request. I note the date it arrives, and I file it with the income figures and the repair schedule attached. If the insurer and you disagree on the net income, the form has an appraisal clause, which my page on the appraisal clause explains.

Tell me what closed your business

The declarations page of your commercial policy, a few photos and the date of the loss are enough to start. Tell me too what kind of business it is and whether any of it is still running. If it was a fire, my page on fire damage claims covers the building and contents side.

I adjust under Illinois license 19461872 and Indiana license 3556317, and I've spent ten years building and repairing the kind of property that closes a business when it breaks. More on that is on my about page.

+1 224-481-2093 volodymyr@staterestoration.us

I answer seven days a week.

My business is closed after damage

What happened, and when did you have to close?

I read every message myself and reply about your claim only.

What business owners ask me first

My business is closed. Do I have business income coverage at all?

Look at the declarations page of your commercial policy for "Business Income" with a limit next to it. A businessowners policy often carries it inside the policy itself. Send me the declarations and I'll tell you what you have.

The insurer paid for the building. Is the lost income a separate claim?

It's a separate coverage under the same loss, with its own limit and its own proof. I keep both parts in one file so the repair schedule and the income figures tell the same story.

I opened again but sales are still down. Is that covered?

On the standard form, extended business income can pay for up to 60 consecutive days after you reopen, or longer if your declarations show an extended period. Keep your daily sales from the first day back.

Do you work with my accountant?

Yes. The figures come from your books, so your accountant's monthly statements and tax returns are the base of the claim. I put them next to the repair schedule and the policy wording.

What does it cost to have you look at it?

The first conversation and the policy review are free. If you hire me, we sign a written contract with my percentage in it before I start.