Fire sprinkler leak claims: water from a sprinkler that froze, broke or went off with no fire
I'm Volodymyr Lukaniuk, a licensed public adjuster in Illinois and Indiana. A wet sprinkler line holds water under pressure all year. When one head or fitting gives way, water runs until someone closes the valve, and in a building with several floors it finds every ceiling on the way down.
Insurers usually accept the wet ceilings. The argument starts over the sprinkler parts, the walls opened to reach the pipe and, after a freeze, the heat in the building. Those are the lines I write and argue for building owners, condo boards and business tenants.
Four ways a sprinkler line lets go, and the policy line each one meets
The cause written in the insurer's file decides which sentence of the policy gets read. Most commercial buildings are insured on the ISO special causes of loss form, CP 10 30, so these cards quote it.
- 1
It froze
A wet pipe in a stairwell, over a loading dock door or in an attic space without heat. The freezing exclusion lists plumbing, heating and air conditioning, then adds "(except fire protective systems)". That exclusion does not reach a frozen sprinkler, and parts damaged directly by freezing are paid.
Exclusion B.2.g, limitation C.4.b - 2
A head was struck
A ladder, a forklift mast, boxes stacked too high, a ball in a gym. Water let out by accident from a broken system is covered, and the form pays for damaged sprinkler parts when the damage set off a discharge from the automatic system.
Limitation C.4.a - 3
A fitting rusted through
Here the insurer quotes wear and tear, rust or corrosion. Those exclusions stop at the rust. When one of them results in a "specified cause of loss", the form pays for the loss from that cause, and leakage from fire-extinguishing equipment is on that list.
Exclusion B.2.d and its last sentence - 4
A head opened with no fire
A heater set too close, an attic that hit summer heat, a faulty head from the factory. The water is read as accidental leakage. Fixing the defect itself is the one part the form leaves out, so I keep the failed head and the contractor's report.
Limitation C.4, first sentence
Wording from ISO form CP 10 30 10 12, Causes of Loss Special Form. Many insurers print their own version, and I read yours next to this one.
Who pays for which part of the repair
A sprinkler claim has four parts. A first estimate often pays the wet finishes and leaves out the rest, so I split the bill the way the form splits it and argue each line on its own.
The tear-out extension does not raise your limit of insurance, so on a large building I check the limit before the estimate goes in. If water stood long enough for mold to grow, the form has a separate $15,000 cap for it, and my mold damage claims page explains how the water part is kept apart from the mold part.
Ceilings, walls, floors and contents the water reached
Covered water damage, on every floor it ran to.
Opening walls and ceilings to reach the broken pipe, then closing them
Extension F.2: "the cost to tear out and replace any part of the building or structure".
Sprinkler heads, pipe and fittings that were damaged
Limitation C.4: paid when the damage set off a discharge or was caused directly by freezing.
Correcting the defect that made it fail
Limitation C.4: "We will not pay the cost to repair any defect to a system".
48 hours: the clock that protects your fire coverage
Many commercial policies carry a Protective Safeguards endorsement. On the ISO version, CP 04 11, the symbol P-1 is the automatic sprinkler system. If it is listed in your schedule, you have to keep it in complete working order and tell the insurer about any impairment you know of. Breaking that condition takes away the coverage for fire.
"if part of an Automatic Sprinkler System ... is shut off due to breakage, leakage, freezing conditions or opening of sprinkler heads, notification to us will not be necessary if you can restore full protection within 48 hours."
So the valve closed to stop the water starts a clock. I ask owners to write down when it was closed and when it was opened again, and to keep the fire protection contractor's note that the system is back in service. When a repair will take longer, the insurer hears it in writing that day.
An Illinois owner who capped a few heads
In Burmac Metal v. West Bend Mutual, 356 Ill. App. 3d 471 (2005), an owner had removed and capped between 3 and 19 of more than 600 heads over an oven, because they kept discharging, and had not told the insurer. After a gas explosion and fire, the court held that the capped heads were a failure to maintain the system, and the claim was lost.
A hotel whose sprinkler couplings froze
In Five Star Hotels v. Insurance Co. of Greater New York (S.D.N.Y. 2011), two couplings froze and burst on upper floors. The insurer called it a failure to maintain the system. The court found the word "maintain" ambiguous, and the endorsement did not defeat the claim.
Endorsement wording and both cases as summarized by IRMI, "Protective Safeguards Endorsements Need a Warning Label". Whether an endorsement can be enforced against you is a question for a lawyer. Getting the dates, the reports and the notice into the file is my part.
A frozen sprinkler: the home form and the commercial form ask opposite things
For an ordinary water pipe, both forms let you choose between keeping the heat on and draining the system. A sprinkler changes that, and the two forms change it in different directions.
Houses and condo buildings
Homeowner form HO 00 03 05 11However, if the building is protected by an automatic fire protective sprinkler system, you must use reasonable care to continue the water supply and maintain heat in the building for coverage to apply.
Draining, the usual way out for a vacant house, is not an option here. Heat and water both have to stay on. Many Chicago condo buildings have sprinklers in corridors and units; the association's side of that claim is on my condo association claims page.
Offices, stores, warehouses, churches
Commercial form CP 10 30 10 12Water ... that leaks or flows from plumbing, heating, air conditioning or other equipment (except fire protective systems) caused by or resulting from freezing
That exclusion leaves sprinklers out. The heat record still matters for the safeguards endorsement above and for the vacancy rule of the building form. The frozen pipe claims page shows how I build that record from thermostat history and gas bills.
Homeowner wording as quoted by Insurance Journal, "Logic & Language, Forms & Facts: Frozen II". Commercial wording from the CP 10 30 form linked above.
What I put in the file after a sprinkler discharge
Sprinkler water moves fast and sideways along the ceiling before it drops, so damage turns up two rooms away and a floor down. I measure moisture room by room on the first visit, so the drying and the repair cover every space the water reached.
I hold Illinois roofing contractor and general contractor licenses, so the ceilings, drywall and floors opened on each level are priced by a builder. When the business had to close, the lost income goes in too, as my business income claims page explains.
Leakage that runs for 14 days or more is excluded, so a slow drip from a fitting in a closed storeroom should be reported the day it is found.
Tell me where the sprinkler let go
Photos of the broken head or pipe, the ceilings below and the valve room are enough to start. If the insurer or your fire protection contractor has already written something, send that too.
I adjust claims under Illinois license No. 19461872 and Indiana license No. 3556317. You can talk to me in English, Ukrainian or Russian, and the about page tells more of my story. For a building with many owners or tenants, the commercial property claims page shows how I report to a board or an owner.
+1 224-481-2093 volodymyr@staterestoration.usI answer seven days a week.
Questions owners and boards ask me about sprinkler water
A sprinkler head went off in one unit and the water reached the floors below. Whose policy pays?
In a condo building, the association's master policy answers for the parts of the building it insures, and each unit owner's own policy answers for what belongs to that owner. In a rental or office building, the owner's building policy pays for the building and each tenant's policy for the tenant's property. If a tenant or a contractor knocked the head, the insurer that paid may try to recover from them later, and that does not hold up your claim.
The insurer paid for the wet ceilings but not the new sprinkler heads. Is that right?
Read limitation C.4 of your causes of loss form. On the standard commercial form, damaged parts of fire-extinguishing equipment are paid when the damage set off a discharge from the automatic system or was caused directly by freezing. The repair of the defect itself is the part the form leaves out.
Should I drain the sprinklers in a building I close for the winter?
Ask your fire protection contractor and your insurer first, in writing. A home policy requires a sprinklered building to keep its water supply and its heat for a freezing loss to be covered, and a commercial policy may list the system as a safeguard you must keep in working order. Draining it can solve one problem and create another.
Can you tell me what my claim will pay?
No, and nobody honestly can before the building is inspected and measured. After the first visit I can show you what got wet, which line of the policy answers for each part of the repair, and what proof each line of the estimate needs.
How soon should I call?
Call your insurer and your fire protection contractor the same day. If your policy has a Protective Safeguards endorsement, closing the valve starts a 48-hour clock, and the policy asks for prompt notice and reasonable steps to protect the property. You can reach me seven days a week.