Detached garage, fence and shed claims: the other structures part of your home policy

I'm Volodymyr Lukaniuk, a licensed public adjuster in Illinois and Indiana. When a tree comes down on the garage, a car takes out the fence or a fire starts in the shed, the claim runs under a different part of your policy than the house does.

That part has its own limit, usually a tenth of the dwelling amount, and its own way of valuing each structure. I find out which piece of the lot sits where, measure what was damaged and argue the claim with your insurer for you.

Alley Street Garage Shed Back porch House Walk B B B B ? A A
  • ADwelling, Coverage A
  • BOther structures, Coverage B
  • ?Depends on how it is joined

How is it joined to the house? That decides which limit pays

The standard home form covers the house "including structures attached to the dwelling". Other structures are those "set apart from the dwelling by clear space". When a garage is close to the house, the argument is over that gap.

  1. A shared wall

    An attached garage, a porch or a sunroom built onto the house. It is part of the dwelling and is paid from the larger house limit.

    Coverage A
  2. Only a fence between them

    The form says it directly: a structure joined to the house "by only a fence, utility line, or similar connection" is still an other structure.

    Coverage B
  3. A power line or pipe

    Electric service run out to the garage, a gas line to a pool heater, a water line to a shed. A utility line alone does not make it attached.

    Coverage B
  4. A roofed walkway

    A breezeway with a roof, a wall or a foundation of its own. Whether it ties the garage to the house depends on how it is built and how your policy is worded. I photograph and measure it before that argument starts.

    Read your policy first

Quotes from the HO 00 03 10 00 form on the Nevada Division of Insurance site, Section I, Coverages A and B. Your insurer may use another edition or its own wording, so I read yours before I quote it.

Work out your other structures limit

Find the dwelling amount, Coverage A, on your declarations page and type it in. The numbers on the right follow the standard form.

$300,000 is only an example. Some policies set a different percentage or list a dollar amount for other structures.
Most the policy pays for all other structures together$30,000"Not more than 10% of the limit of liability that applies to Coverage A." Using it does not lower the house limit.
Extra for hauling the debris away$1,500Debris removal is paid inside the limit. When the damage and the debris together come to more than the limit, another 5% of that limit is added for the debris.
Code work, shared with the house$30,000Ordinance or law: up to 10% of the dwelling limit for costs a building rule adds to the repair of a "covered building or other structure". One amount for the whole loss.

The garage, the fence and the shed all come out of the first amount together. A full garage rebuild on a lot with a long fence can reach it, which is why I price each structure separately and look for every other part of the policy that applies before the claim is closed. The underpaid claims I handle are explained on my underpaid claim help page.

Rented out, or used for work: four cases the form treats differently

The standard form leaves out an other structure that is rented to someone outside the household, used to run a business, or used to store business property. Each rule has a limit to it.

  • Rented to a neighbour to park a car

    Rental is excluded "unless used solely as a private garage". If only cars are kept in it, the rent does not take the cover away.

    Covered
  • Rented out as a workshop or storage

    A structure "rented or held for rental to any person not a tenant of the dwelling" for anything else falls outside Coverage B.

    Excluded
  • A business run from it

    A body shop, a studio with customers, a small trade run from the garage. "Other structures from which any business is conducted" are excluded.

    Excluded
  • Your own work tools stored in it

    Business property owned by you or a tenant of the house is allowed, as long as no gas or liquid fuel is stored there other than in a vehicle's own tank.

    Covered

Coverage B, item 2, of the HO 00 03 10 00 form linked above. If a business uses part of the garage, a business policy may answer for it, and I ask what other policies you have before the claim is filed.

A garage is paid as a building, a fence is not

The form pays "buildings covered under Coverage A or B at replacement cost", without taking off for age when the 80 percent condition is met. "Structures that are not buildings" are paid at actual cash value, which does take off for age. So the first question about each piece is whether it is a building.

StructureHow the standard form values itWhat I check on it
Detached garageReplacement costSlab, framing, roof, overhead door and opener, electrical, and the permit work a rebuild needs.
Shed or workshopReplacement costWhether it is a building with walls and a roof, and what is stored in it (see the signs below).
Gazebo or pergolaDepends on the buildA roofed gazebo on footings is closer to a building than an open pergola. I photograph how it is built.
Fence and gatesActual cash valueLength, height, posts, gates and today's price. Damage from ice or frozen ground is excluded for fences.
Driveway and walksActual cash valueCracking from a truck or a fallen tree. The same ice and freezing exclusion reaches pavement and patios.
Retaining wallActual cash valueWhether it holds up part of a building. A free-standing wall is excluded from freezing and ice damage.

From the same HO 00 03 10 00 form: Section I Conditions, Loss Settlement, and Perils Insured Against A.2.c(2). Many insurers change the valuation by endorsement, so I check your declarations for it.

What I put in the file for a garage, fence or shed

I hold Illinois roofing contractor and general contractor licenses, so a garage is priced the way a builder would price it, from the slab to the ridge. The house and the other structures are written as separate parts of one claim, so nothing is lost between the two limits.

What is stored inside the garage is a third part. Tools, bikes, the mower and the car parts on the shelf are personal property, paid under Coverage C, and my personal property claims page explains the limits that apply to them.

Most garage claims I see start with a tree or a vehicle. The fallen tree damage claims page covers the crew bill and the tree removal amounts, and the car into house damage claims page covers the driver's insurance next to yours.

0 ft2 ft4 ft6 ft8 ft10 ft
  1. Photos of every side of each damaged structure, and a wide photo showing where it stands on the lot.
  2. The gap between the garage and the house measured, and any breezeway, shared roof or shared foundation photographed.
  3. Fence runs measured in feet, with the height, the post count and every gate.
  4. The garage measured and its parts listed: slab, walls, roof, overhead door, opener, wiring and windows.
  5. What the garage or shed was used for, written down, so the rental and business rules are answered before they are asked.
  6. A separate list of the things stored inside, with photos.
Portrait of Volodymyr Lukaniuk, public adjuster

Tell me what happened to the garage or fence

A few photos and the insurer's letter or estimate, if you have one, are enough to start. I'll tell you which part of the policy each structure falls under and what I would check first.

I adjust claims under Illinois license No. 19461872 and Indiana license No. 3556317, and I speak English, Ukrainian and Russian. More about me is on the about page.

+1 224-481-2093 volodymyr@staterestoration.us

I answer seven days a week.

Garage, fence or shed damage

What was damaged, and what has the insurer said so far?

I read every message myself and reply about your claim only.

Questions owners ask me about garage and fence claims

Does my deductible apply again to the garage if the house was damaged in the same storm?

On the standard home form there is one deductible for one loss, taken from the total. The garage and the house are two parts of the same claim, not two claims. Your own declarations page may say otherwise, so I read it first.

The garage was a total loss and the 10 percent ran out. Is there anything else?

Three places to look: the extra 5 percent for debris removal when the damage and the debris together pass the limit, the code amount if the City requires changes in the rebuild, and any endorsement that raised the other structures limit. I check all three before the claim is closed.

My fence is old. Will they really pay so little?

A fence is a structure that is not a building, so the standard form pays its actual cash value, which takes wear into account. What I argue is the number itself: the length, the height, the posts, the gates and the cost to build it today, before any wear is taken off.

Can you tell me what my garage claim will pay?

Nobody can honestly promise an amount before the garage is inspected and measured, and I don't. After the first visit I can tell you which part of the policy it sits under, how it will be valued and what the limit allows.