Evanston public adjuster: claims for water in the basement, storm damage and fire

I'm Volodymyr Lukaniuk, a licensed public adjuster in Illinois and a licensed roofer and general contractor. I work for Evanston owners, not their insurer, on houses, condo buildings and two-flats.

The question I hear most in Evanston comes after a storm: is the water in my basement covered? The City of Evanston already sorts that water into two kinds, and your policy reads those two kinds with different words. That sort is where your claim starts.

Clear waterStorm water in through a window well or a door
Dark, with an odourSewage backed up into the basement

The two kinds of basement flooding on the City of Evanston sewer page

Is basement water covered in Evanston? It depends which of the two it was

The city is served entirely by a combined sewer, one pipe for both storm water and sewage. In a heavy rain that pipe fills, and water can reach a basement from outside or from below. A standard homeowner policy names each route separately, so I write down which one it was before anything is thrown out.

What the city calls it
The words your insurer reads
What I record in the basement
Clear water
Storm water that came in through window wells or doors. The city says it can't fix this kind, and asks you to report it anyway.
The standard form leaves out flood and surface water, and water below the ground that seeps through a foundation. Most base policies don't pay for it.
Where it came in, the mark it left on the wall, and whether a broken window or a roof leak let it in first, because those can change the answer.
Dark, with an odour
Sewage that backed up into the basement. The city asks you to call it in and not to run water down the drains.
Water that backs up through sewers or drains. Excluded on the base form, and paid through a backup endorsement up to its own limit.
The floor drain, the cleanout and the sump pit, the height on the walls, and the endorsement limit on your declarations page.
Water from above
Not a sewer matter at all, so it isn't on the city's page.
Rain through a roof or wall that wind or hail opened first, or a pipe that burst inside. The policy treats these as their own causes.
The opening on the roof or wall, the path the water took down the house, and the ceilings it stained on the way.

Sources: the City of Evanston Sewer Systems page, and the water exclusion in the HO 00 03 10 00 homeowner form. Your insurer may use its own wording, so I read your policy, not a sample. If it was the dark kind, my page on sewer and drain backup claims goes through the endorsement line by line.

Call the city the night it happens. The call is a dated record

Evanston asks residents to report sewer backups, and the report does two jobs. The Sewer Division can check the main for a blockage, and you get a date and time on file that matches your photos.

An insurer will ask when the water came and how fast it rose. A city report made that night, next to your own photos with the time on them, answers both questions without anyone having to remember.

Then photograph the water before you pump it, keep a jar of it if it was dark, and don't throw out wet carpet or drywall until it has been photographed and measured.

Evanston sewer backup: who to call

7 a.m. to 7 p.m.
311
From outside the city
847-448-4311
After hours
847-475-6880
Utilities Department emergency line

Numbers as the City of Evanston lists them on its combined sewer page. Write down the time you called.

Evanston rebuilt its sewers. Why your insurer may still mention them

In 1990 the City Council approved a long range program to cut down on sewage backing up into basements. It was built from 1991 to 2008 and cost about $210 million.

1990 approved1991 to 2008 built: relief sewers, inlet restrictors, some separate storm sewers$210 million

The work changed how often basements back up. It didn't change your policy. A claim is decided by the words on your form and the endorsement you carry, whatever the city's pipes did that night.

Restrictors in street and alley inlets hold rain on the surface for a while so the sewer doesn't overload. That is useful for the house and awkward for the claim: water standing at the curb is surface water, and some of it can find a window well.

So I separate the routes room by room. Backup through the floor drain, rain through a broken window and seepage through a wall each go into the file with their own photos, and each is argued under its own words.

The city paperwork behind an Evanston repair, and the estimate lines it adds

A repair estimate that leaves out the city's steps is short before anyone argues about prices. Each step below takes time or money, so each one is a line I put in the estimate and send to the insurer with its source.

On a roof or a wall the street can see, the preservation step is the one owners don't expect. My page on tile and slate roof claims covers the search for matching pieces when an older roof is damaged.

  1. Permit

    Apply through the Citizen Portal

    Evanston takes building permit applications online only, with electronic plans. Exterior work also needs a current plat of survey.

  2. Preservation

    Check About My Place for a district or landmark

    The city's map shows whether a property sits in a local historic district or is a landmark. If it does, exterior work seen from the street needs a Certificate of Appropriateness.

  3. Like for like

    Routine maintenance still files the form

    Repair with the same design and materials is treated as routine maintenance, and the city still asks for the application with the permit.

  4. Review

    Plan review by Building and Zoning staff

    Some projects also go to Engineering, Preservation or Fire. The weeks this takes belong in the repair schedule and in any living expense claim.

Hands holding a home insurance form on a clipboard

Condo buildings, two-flats and houses: whose policy answers

In a condo building, a basement backup or a roof leak often lands on several owners at once. The building's claim goes through the association's master policy, and each owner's unit and belongings go through their own.

When a board or a property manager calls me, I adjust the building claim and keep the owners' claims in step with it. My page on condo association claims explains how the master policy is read for the building.

On a house or a two-flat, the roof, the siding and the basement are usually one claim from one storm, and I document all of them on the first visit.

Tell me what happened to your Evanston property

Photos of the basement walls, the floor drain and the water before it was pumped are enough to start. Tell me the date, and whether you called the city or your insurer already.

I adjust under Illinois public adjuster license No. 19461872, I'm a HAAG-certified inspector, and I speak English, Ukrainian and Russian. You can read more about my background.

+1 224-481-2093 volodymyr@staterestoration.us

I answer seven days a week.

Damage to my Evanston property

Basement water, storm, fire? Tell me when it happened.

I read every message myself and reply about your claim only.

What Evanston owners ask me

Do you come to Evanston for an inspection?

Yes. My office is on North Long Avenue in Chicago, about nine miles from Evanston City Hall, and I inspect in Evanston the same way I do in the city.

My basement had both kinds of water. What then?

That happens in a heavy storm. I separate the two in the file: where each came in, how high it rose, and what each one damaged, so the parts your policy pays for aren't lost inside the parts it doesn't.

The insurer says the city sewer caused it, so the city should pay. Is that right?

Your claim with your insurer is decided by your policy, whatever the cause outside the house. A claim against the city is a separate matter that I don't handle, because it is a legal question and I'm not a lawyer.

My house is in a historic district. Will the insurer pay for matching materials?

The policy pays to repair with material of like kind and quality. When the city's preservation review asks for a specific material on the street side, I put that requirement and its source in the estimate.

What does it cost to have you look at it?

The first visit and the policy review cost nothing. If you hire me, we sign a written contract with my percentage in it before I start any work on the claim.