Car into house damage claims: whose policy pays for which part

I'm Volodymyr Lukaniuk, a licensed public adjuster in Illinois and Indiana. When a car crashes into a house, a two-flat or a storefront, two insurers get involved: the driver's auto company and yours. They pay in a set order, and each one pays only for certain parts of the damage.

I work on the claim under your own policy. I write the repair scope as the licensed contractor I am, and I keep track of what the driver's insurer has paid so nothing is missed between the two.

Write this down before the tow truck leaves

Everything on this card comes from the scene. It is harder to get a week later.

  • Police report (RD) number
  • Driver's name and phone
  • Owner of the vehicle, if not the driver
  • Plate number and state
  • Auto insurer and policy number
  • Did someone who lives here drive?
  • Photos: wall, porch, car in place, skid marks

The order the money comes in after a car hits your house

Most of the answers online stop at "the driver's insurance pays first, up to its limits". The limit is the part that matters, so here are the three steps with the Illinois number in them.

  1. 1

    The driver's auto policy: property damage liability

    If the driver is at fault, their auto policy owes for damage to other people's property, buildings included. In Illinois the legal minimum for that coverage is $20,000 per accident, and some drivers carry only the minimum.

    That one limit is shared by everything the car hit in the same crash: your building, a parked car, the neighbour's fence, a light pole.

    Your buildingParked carFence next door
    One limit per accident, split between everyone who has a claim. The shares are drawn for illustration only.
  2. 2

    Your homeowner policy: the rest of the repair

    Your own policy answers for the house under Coverage A, the garage and fence under Coverage B and your belongings under Coverage C, minus your deductible. If the driver had no insurance or drove off, this is where the whole claim lands.

    Nothing in the standard HO 00 03 form asks you to collect from the driver before you claim. Report the crash to your own insurer in writing as soon as you can.

  3. 3

    Your insurer goes after the driver

    Under the subrogation condition, your insurer may ask you to sign over your right to recover from the driver, to the extent it paid you. It then collects from the driver's company. I ask your insurer in writing whether that recovery will include your deductible, and I keep the letters.

The $20,000 figure is from the Illinois Department of Insurance auto insurance guide, which cites 625 ILCS 5/7-203 and lists buildings among the property this coverage pays for. The homeowner wording on this page is from the ISO form HO 00 03 10 00; your own policy may carry other forms or endorsements, and I read yours line by line.

Who was driving changes some answers, not all of them

A crash by a stranger and a crash by someone who lives in the house read differently in only one clause of the HO 00 03 form. The table shows where.

What was hitA stranger or a neighbour droveSomeone who lives here drove
The houseYour policy, after the driver's limitCoverage A insures the dwelling against risk of direct physical loss, and no exclusion names vehicles.Your policyThe same open-peril wording applies. It does not ask who was behind the wheel.
Garage, porch steps, fenceYour policy under Coverage BOther structures share the open-peril wording.A fence is a structure that is not a building, so the form settles it at actual cash value.Your policy under Coverage BSame wording, same actual cash value rule for the fence.
Trees, shrubs, lawnCovered, with small limitsVehicles are a named cause in the trees clause: up to 5% of the dwelling limit in total, no more than $500 for one tree or shrub.Not under that clauseIt covers only a vehicle "not owned or operated by a resident" of the home.
Your belongings insideYour policy under Coverage CPeril 6, Vehicles: "impact from a vehicle".Your policy under Coverage CPeril 6 has no resident exception.
The car itselfNot under the home policyPeril 6 leaves out "damage to the vehicle itself". The car goes to an auto policy.Not under the home policyMotor vehicles are not covered property in Coverage C.

Furniture, clothes and electronics knocked over or crushed by the car are valued item by item, the way the personal property claims page explains. A tree the car pushed onto the roof is a different case from a tree that fell in the wind; the fallen tree claims page covers that one.

1 2 3 4 5
A typical front-of-building hit on a brick two-flat. The numbers match the list beside the drawing, and each one is a separate trade in my estimate.

What a car does to a Chicago brick building, written as a repair scope

  1. Porch posts and the beam they carry

    A post knocked out of line puts the porch roof and the floor above on temporary shores. Shoring and the rebuilt posts, beam and footing are separate lines.

  2. Brick face and the lintel over the window

    A cracked steel lintel or a bulged section of brick means taking the wall down to sound masonry and relaying it, with brick matched to the rest of the front.

  3. The window and its frame

    Glass, sash, frame and the interior trim around it, priced together with the masonry they sit in.

  4. Gas meter and electric service on the side wall

    If the car reached the side of the building, the meter, the piping and the service entrance are checked and repaired by licensed trades, and their bills go in the claim.

  5. The front room

    Framing, drywall, flooring and the furniture behind the wall. Debris removal is part of the claim too.

Two lines in the form help here. Reasonable repairs to protect the building from further damage are paid, so shoring and boarding go in the claim with their receipts. And the policy pays actual cash value until the work is done, then the rest of the replacement cost, which is why I track the claim to the final payment. When the insurer's estimate leaves trades out, the underpaid claim page explains how the missing lines are argued.

Living costs and lost rent while the front of the building is shored

Coverage D of the HO 00 03 form has two parts that matter after a crash, one for the floor you live on and one for a floor you rent out.

The part of the house where you live

"we cover any necessary increase in living expenses incurred by you so that your household can maintain its normal standard of living"

It applies when a covered loss makes that part of the house not fit to live in, and it lasts for the shortest time needed to repair it. The guide to additional living expenses in Illinois shows how the receipts are kept.

The unit you rent out

"we cover the fair rental value of such premises less any expenses that do not continue while it is not fit to live in"

If the tenant's unit can't be lived in after the crash, the rent is part of your claim. Owners of two-flats and small apartment buildings will find the details on the rental building claims page.

Getting the crash report in Chicago

Both insurers will ask for the police report. In Chicago the police give an RD number when the report is made, and that number is how every copy of the report is found later.

The Chicago Police Department's guidance on requesting a police report lists traffic crash reports among the documents its records section releases.

Online

The department runs a Traffic Crash Reports site at crash.chicagopolice.org. Have the RD number ready.

In person or by mail

Records Inquiry and Customer Service Section, 3510 S. Michigan Ave., Chicago, IL 60653.

Outside Chicago

If a suburban department or the state police came, the report comes from that agency. I add it to the claim file either way.

Portrait of Volodymyr Lukaniuk, public adjuster

Show me the wall the car hit

Photos of the outside and the inside, the RD number and the driver's insurance details are enough to start. If either insurer has already sent you an estimate or a letter, send that too.

My Illinois public adjuster license is No. 19461872 and my Indiana one is No. 3556317. I also hold an Illinois roofing contractor license and a general contractor license, so the repair scope is written by someone who builds. I speak English, Ukrainian and Russian. More about my work is on the about page.

+1 224-481-2093 volodymyr@staterestoration.us

I answer seven days a week.

A car hit the building

When did it happen, and which part of the building was hit?

I read every message myself and reply about your claim only.

What owners ask me after a car hits the house

The driver's insurer called me first. Should I take their estimate?

You can listen to it, but check what it covers before you sign a release. Their adjuster writes for the driver's company, and the money they offer comes out of a limit that may be small and shared. I compare their numbers with the full repair, trade by trade, so you know what is left to claim on your own policy.

Do I have to wait for the driver's company before I claim on my own policy?

Nothing in the standard HO 00 03 form asks you to collect from the driver first. Report the crash to your own insurer right away, in writing, and give them the driver's details. Your insurer can pay you under your policy and then go after the driver itself.

Someone in my family backed into the garage. Is that covered?

The garage is an other structure under Coverage B, and the open-peril wording in the HO 00 03 form has no exception for who was driving. The hedge or the tree the car flattened on the way in is different: that clause leaves out vehicles owned or driven by someone who lives in the house.

The front room is propped up with posts. Can we stay somewhere else?

If the crash makes the part of the house you live in unfit to live in, Coverage D pays the increase in your living costs for the shortest time needed to repair it. Keep every hotel and meal receipt, and write down why the room is unsafe.

Will you tell me what the claim is worth?

Nobody can honestly promise an amount before the building is opened up and measured, and I don't. After the first visit I can show you which policy answers for each part, what the repair involves, and what proof each line of the estimate needs.