Vandalism and break-in damage claims for Chicago buildings
Someone forced the door, cut into the walls for copper or wrecked the place on the way through. I'm a licensed public adjuster, and I handle the claim for the damage they left in your building, from the first inspection to the talks with your insurer.
The bars show the idea, not a measurement from one building. Merlin Law Group writes that the structure usually costs far more than the metal, and that is why these claims get argued.
One break-in, six kinds of damage
A drawing of no real building. The tents mark what I look for when I walk a property after a burglary, and each one is argued on its own wording.
The way in
Pried door, split frame, cut lock. This is the part insurers argue least, so photograph it before anyone boards it up.
Ceilings and walls opened
Drywall pulled down to reach pipe and wire. The size of this line usually decides whether the claim is small or large.
The electrical panel
Breakers and feeders ripped out. An electrician's written finding shows what has to be replaced to pass inspection.
The cooling unit on the roof
Coils and lines cut. Thieves may cross the roof to get there, so I check the membrane too, as on my commercial property claims page.
A water line left running
A cut pipe can flood the floor below overnight. That becomes a water damage claim inside the break-in, with a drying record of its own.
Glass, paint and plain wreckage
Smashed windows, graffiti, fixtures broken for no gain to anyone. Damage with no theft behind it is the clearest vandalism in the file.
The form named on your declarations page changes the copper answer
Look for one word on a commercial policy: Special, Broad or Basic. A home policy is its own form. This is how the standard wording reads, and your insurer may print its own version.
| What happened | Commercial, Special formCP 10 30 | Commercial, Basic or Broadvandalism is a listed cause | Home policyHO 00 03, the house itself |
|---|---|---|---|
| Door or window forced | Covered as direct physical loss. | Covered: the wording keeps building damage from burglars "breaking in or exiting". | Covered as direct physical loss. |
| Installed copper taken | Theft by an outsider is not excluded. Loose materials not yet attached are limited. | Theft is carved out of the vandalism cause. | Not excluded, unless the house is under construction. |
| Walls cut to reach it | Covered as direct physical loss. | The fight. Owners call it vandalism, insurers call it part of the theft. | Covered as direct physical loss. |
| Graffiti and smashed fixtures | Covered as direct physical loss. | Covered as vandalism. | Covered, unless the 60-day vacancy line applies. |
Courts split on that third row. In March 2026 a federal court in Colorado sided with the insurer on a stripped Denver warehouse, in BWB Investment v. Scottsdale, and the same blog reports other owners who recovered. What a clause means in court is an attorney's question. Separating and pricing the damage is mine.
So I write the estimate to show what was stolen, what was cut to reach it, and what was broken for no reason, each on its own lines. Stock and equipment are a separate part of the claim: my article on missing inventory covers a business, and personal property claims covers a home. An endorsement such as CP 10 33 can also take theft out, so I read the forms list too.
Wording from CP 10 30 10 12 and CP 00 10 10 12, HO 00 03 10 00 and the Basic form language quoted by FC&S. Deductibles and limits still apply.
Day 60: the count your insurer makes first
Empty buildings get broken into, so a vandalism or theft claim usually starts with one question: how long had the place been vacant?
The 60 days before the loss, one square a day
- Past day 30, Chicago's owner rules apply to a vacant building: secure it, carry liability insurance, register it, post a sign and visit regularly.
- Past day 60, the standard commercial form stops paying for the causes listed below. Other covered causes are paid less 15%.
- Vandalism
- Sprinkler leakage, unless protected against freezing
- Building glass breakage
- Water damage
- Theft
- Attempted theft
On the home form, the 60-day line sits on vandalism and the loss that follows from it. My article on a vacant house with a burst pipe shows how that question plays out for water.
The 31% test for a building owner
A building counts as vacant unless at least 31% of its square footage is rented and used by tenants, or used by you, for customary operations. A tenant's policy has a different test: enough business property in the unit to operate.
Buildings under construction or renovation are not considered vacant, so permits and contractor invoices belong in the file. In West Bend v. New Packing, an unpublished Illinois appellate decision from 2011, an insurer that could have inspected before insuring the building could not rely on this exclusion.
Four lines of your policy to act on before the boards go up
These are from the duties section of the standard commercial form. Beside each one is what I'd ask you to keep.
"Notify the police if a law may have been broken."
Make the report the day you find it, and save the report number and the officer's name. On a home policy the duty is written for theft.
"Give us prompt notice of the loss or damage."
A short written notice with the date you found it. Leave out guesses about who did it or how much it will cost.
"Take all reasonable steps to protect the Covered Property from further damage."
Board up, shut off the water and lock the roof hatch, then keep each invoice. Photograph every opening first, from far away and close up.
"...set the damaged property aside..."
Keep the cut pipe ends, the broken lock and the gutted panel cover. Ask your alarm and camera companies to save their logs and footage today.
A break-in claim is several repair jobs written as one
I'm a licensed general contractor and roofing contractor as well as a public adjuster, so I can scope damage that crosses these trades without waiting on a stack of separate bids:
- Doors and glass
- Drywall and ceilings
- Electrical
- Plumbing
- Heating and cooling
- Roof
The first look at the building and the policy costs you nothing. If we go ahead, my percentage goes into a written contract before any work starts, and there's no payment up front. Already have a letter refusing the claim? Start with my denied claim help page.
Tell me what you found at the building
The date you found it, whether the building was in use, and a police report number if you have one. I speak English, Ukrainian and Russian.
+1 224-481-2093 volodymyr@staterestoration.usWeekdays I pick up from 7 AM to 7 PM. Saturdays and Sundays, 9 AM to 5 PM.
What owners ask after a break-in
Who pays for the door and frame after a break-in?
The building coverage of your policy normally answers for it, after the deductible, unless a vacancy condition applies. If you rent the space, check your lease for who insures the building before you file.
Thieves took the copper out of my building. Is that theft or vandalism?
On a Special form you may not need the label, because theft is not excluded for an outsider. On a Basic or Broad form the label decides a lot, and owners and insurers argue it. I start by reading which form your declarations page names.
My building is empty while I look for a tenant. Am I still covered?
Count the days and measure the space. On the standard commercial form, vandalism and theft drop out after more than 60 days of vacancy, and an owner needs 31% of the square footage in use to stay outside that test. A renovation under way does not count as vacant.
Do I need a police report for graffiti or a broken window?
Yes, I would make one. The commercial form tells you to notify the police if a law may have been broken, and the report number gives the insurer a date and a place on record.
The thieves came back a second time. Is that a new claim?
Usually each break-in is its own occurrence with its own deductible, so keep the two sets of photos and reports apart. Your insurer will also look at what you did to protect the building after the first one, so keep the board-up invoice.
I represent policyholders as a licensed public adjuster, and I'm not an attorney. No one can tell you ahead of time what an insurer will pay on a break-in, because that turns on your own policy and the proof in the file.