Snow on the roof: when your policy calls it a collapse, and when it doesn't

I'm Volodymyr Lukaniuk, a licensed public adjuster in Illinois and Indiana and a licensed roofer and general contractor. When snow cracks a rafter or brings a ceiling down, I go into the attic, measure what happened, and hold the insurer to the words of your policy.

Still standing

The roof sags

A part that is standing isn't a collapse on the standard form, even if it bends or sags. It goes down another route in the policy.

In danger of falling

A rafter cracks

A roof that might come down isn't a collapse either. Prop it, photograph it with the date, and call your insurer the same day.

Collapse

It caves in

An abrupt falling down that leaves the room unusable. This is the event the collapse clause pays for.

The four sentences that decide a snow collapse claim

On the standard homeowner form they sit under Additional Coverages, item 8. Your insurer may use another edition or its own form, so I read yours first. Here is the common wording, and what I record against each line.

a.(1)Collapse means an abrupt falling down or caving in of a building or any part of a building with the result that the building or part of the building cannot be occupied for its current intended purpose.

I note when it came down, if anyone heard it, and whether the room under it can still be used. A bedroom with the ceiling on the bed can't.

a.(2)A building or any part of a building that is in danger of falling down or caving in is not considered to be in a state of collapse.

If it hasn't fallen, I photograph the props and the cracks with a date. Should it come down later, the file already shows the order of events.

a.(3)A part of a building that is standing is not considered to be in a state of collapse even if it has separated from another part of the building.

A porch roof pulling away from the wall belongs here. I measure the gap and look at the ledger board and its fasteners.

a.(4)...even if it shows evidence of cracking, bulging, sagging, bending, leaning, settling, shrinkage or expansion.

I measure sag with a string line along the ridge and the rafters, so the estimate shows how far each member moved and where.

Snow is named twice in the list of causes

Part b of the clause lists six causes. The collapse is covered when one of them brought the building, or part of it, down. Two of them are snow: the tiles with a filled number and a heavy top edge.

  1. The causes named for your belongings

    That list includes the weight of ice, snow or sleet. My page on personal property claims goes through the rest of it.

  2. Decay hidden from view

    Rot inside a rafter or a wall counts, unless someone in the household knew about it before the collapse.

  3. Insects or vermin hidden from view

    The same rule as decay: covered while hidden, out once it was known.

  4. Weight of contents, equipment, animals or people

    A loaded attic floor, a platform under a water heater, or a crowd on a balcony built onto the house.

  5. Weight of rain or snow which collects on a roof

    The plainest snow cause. Drifts behind a parapet or below a higher roof land here, and so does snow and water ponding on a flat roof.

  6. Defective material or methods in construction

    Only when the collapse happens while the building, remodeling or renovation work is going on.

Wording from the HO 00 03 10 00 form on the Nevada Division of Insurance site, Section I, Additional Coverages, item 8 Collapse, and Coverage C peril 11.

Write the snow down before it melts

A snow claim is an argument about timing. The insurer asks how much snow sat on the roof, for how long, and whether the framing was weak before it came. A thaw takes that evidence away within days.

Keep a line for every heavy snowfall this winter, on paper or in your phone. Photos from the street count, and so do photos taken through the attic hatch. My roof damage claims page covers what else I check on the shingles and decking afterwards.

An example line. Copy the headings onto paper or into a note on your phone and add a line each time it snows.
DateSnow that fellDepth on the roofPhotosSounds, cracks, doorsCleared by
ExampleFrom the local news or weather reportMeasured from a window with a yardstickStreet side, back, attic hatchCreaking at night, new crack above the hall doorRoof rake from the ground, or a crew with their bill
Insurance claim papers and a laptop on a desk

If the roof sagged but didn't fall

The dwelling part of the form covers risk of direct physical loss, then sets aside loss involving collapse and sends it to item 8. A rafter that cracked and held is not a collapse, so it comes back to that broad dwelling coverage.

There an insurer may quote the exclusion for settling, shrinking, bulging or expansion of roofs or ceilings. Those words describe slow movement over years. A rafter that split in one storm, with a fresh break and snow still on top of it, is a sudden event, and I document it as one.

If the insurer has already written to say no, my page on denied claims explains how a decision like that is answered.

  • Close photo of the break
  • Colour of the wood inside the crack
  • Moisture reading
  • String-line sag measurement
  • Date and snow depth that day

What you knew about the wood before the snow came

Hidden decay is one of the six causes only while nobody in the household knew about it. So the insurer may ask what you knew, and when.

The papers from buying the house and from past roof work answer that question. A home inspection that found no rot in the attic, or a roofer's invoice that replaced every soft board, shows the framing was sound as far as you could tell. Find them before the inspection, not after.

I read each one before the insurer's adjuster arrives, so nothing in your own file surprises us at the meeting.

Home inspection reportFrom when you bought the house, the attic and roof pages
Roofer invoicesEach reroof or repair, with what they replaced
Old photos of the atticFrom insulation work, a move-in, a listing
PermitsFor any addition or dormer that changed the roof
  • Awning
  • Fence
  • Patio
  • Deck
  • Pavement
  • Swimming pool
  • Underground pipe
  • Flue
  • Drain
  • Cesspool
  • Septic tank
  • Foundation
  • Retaining wall
  • Bulkhead
  • Pier, wharf, dock

The deck, the fence and the awning

Part c names these structures, and on their own they don't come in through causes 2 to 6. They do come in when the collapse of the house itself damaged them. A porch roof that falls onto the deck brings the deck into the claim with it.

Part d adds that the coverage doesn't raise your limit. The collapse is paid inside the dwelling or other structures limit, so I read your declarations page before I compare any numbers with the insurer.

Snow that falls through the hole onto furniture, rugs and clothes is a contents loss too, priced item by item.

Tell me what the snow did

Phone photos from the street and through the attic hatch are enough to start, with the date the snow fell. Tell me too if the insurer has been out already.

My Illinois public adjuster license is No. 19461872 and my Indiana license is No. 3556317. I'm also a HAAG-certified inspector, and I speak English, Ukrainian and Russian. You can read more about my background.

+1 224-481-2093 volodymyr@staterestoration.us

Open seven days a week.

Snow damage to my roof

Did it sag, crack or come down, and when?

I read every message myself and reply about your claim only.

What owners ask me in a snowy winter

Should I get up on the roof and clear the snow?

No. Use a roof rake from the ground or hire a crew, and keep their bill. If the roof is already damaged, the form pays reasonable costs to protect the house from more damage.

My ceiling cracked but nothing fell. Do I still have a claim?

Often, yes, but under the main dwelling coverage rather than the collapse clause. I look at what broke, when it broke, and what the insurer can point to.

Does it matter that my house is old?

Age isn't one of the six causes and it isn't an exclusion on its own. The question is decay or damage that someone in the household knew about before the snow.

The insurer sent someone already. Can you still help?

Yes. I read their report against what I find in the attic, and against the four sentences of the collapse clause in your policy.

What does it cost to have you look at it?

Nothing for the first look at the attic. If you hire me, we sign a contract with my percentage in it first, and on a home you live in Illinois law limits that percentage to 10%.