Church insurance claims: the building, the glass and the heat in the week

I'm Volodymyr Lukaniuk, a licensed public adjuster in Illinois and Indiana. I represent churches and other houses of worship when a storm, a fire, a burst pipe or a break-in damages the sanctuary, the hall or the parish house. The insurer has its adjuster, and the congregation gets one of its own.

A church policy is a commercial property policy, and it reads differently from a homeowner's. Below are the clauses where I see church claims decided: what broke the statue, how the rain got in, whether the heat was on midweek, and what the building code adds to an old sanctuary.

Which part of the policy answers for it

Sorted from the Maryland Insurance Administration's guide for places of worship

Building

  • The walls, roof and everything permanently attached
  • The steeple
  • Pews installed in place
  • Stained glass and its protective covering
  • Fixtures and signage

Personal property

  • Portable sound equipment
  • Kitchen and hall appliances
  • Outdoor furniture
  • Clergy personal effects, if the policy lists them

Each side has its own limit, and some items carry a smaller one of their own. The guide's example is $5,000 for signage.

Who or what broke it decides whether the statue is paid

Most church policies are written on the special causes of loss form, which covers any direct physical loss that is not excluded. One limitation in it reaches into every sanctuary.

"We will not pay for loss of or damage to the following types of property unless caused by the 'specified causes of loss' or building glass breakage: ... Fragile articles such as statuary, marbles, chinaware and porcelains, if broken. This restriction does not apply to: (1) Glass"

Paid when one of these broke it

  • Windstorm or hail
  • Fire
  • Lightning
  • Smoke
  • Explosion
  • Vandalism
  • Riot
  • Falling objects
  • Weight of snow, ice or sleet
  • Water damage from a broken system
  • Aircraft or vehicles
  • Sprinkler leakage

A plaster saint thrown down by a vandal, a marble font cracked by a branch through the roof, porcelain broken when the ceiling came down under snow: each one names a cause on the list. I write the cause into the claim with the photos and the police or weather record that proves it. Break-ins are a story of their own, told on the vandalism and break-in claims page.

Outside that clause

  • A statue tipped over while the floor was being cleaned
  • Chinaware dropped while the hall was set up
  • A marble piece cracked during moving

Glass is carved out of the restriction, so a stained glass window broken by accident is still read under the open wording. Some churches also carry a fine arts endorsement with its own rules, and I read that first when it is there.

Clause quoted from ISO form CP 10 30 10 12, Causes of Loss Special Form, limitation C.2.b, and the list of specified causes from its definitions. Your policy may use a different edition or the insurer's own form.

  1. The roof or a wall is damaged first

    Wind lifts the slate, hail breaks the tile, a branch opens the flashing at the base of the steeple. That opening has to be caused by something the policy covers.

  2. Rain or snow comes in through that opening

    Water on the plaster, the pews and the organ loft is paid because it came through the damaged roof or wall.

  3. Or snow and ice thaw on the building

    Melt from snow or ice sitting on the church is a second route the form allows. An ice dam over the side aisle is the usual case.

Rain on the pews: the roof has to be read first

The special form does not pay for rain, snow, sleet, ice, sand or dust inside a building unless the roof or walls first took damage from a covered cause, or the water came from snow or ice thawing on the building. So the inside of a church claim is won or lost on the roof.

Sanctuaries have steep, high roofs that the insurer's adjuster often photographs from the ground. I hold an Illinois roofing contractor license and a HAAG inspector certification, and I document the roof up close, slope by slope. Low-slope roofs over a parish hall or school wing are a different system, and the commercial roof damage claims page explains how I test them. Ice dams over the eaves are covered in the guide to ice dam damage in Illinois.

A building heated on Sunday and set back on Tuesday

Many churches save on heat between services, and that is where winter claims get questioned. The special form pays for water from a pipe that froze only on one of two conditions.

A typical week, drawn for illustration. A setback is fine; heat switched off in a building that was not drained is the problem.

Option 1: "You do your best to maintain heat in the building"

The thermostat history, the gas bills for the month and the boiler service record show the heat stayed on. Many smart thermostats keep that history; I ask for it before the insurer does.

Option 2: "You drain the equipment and shut off the supply"

For a chapel or a hall closed for the winter. The date it was drained and who did it belong in the claim file.

Both conditions are in exclusion B.2.g of the same form. A separate exclusion, B.2.f, leaves out leakage that went on for 14 days or more, which is why a leak in a closed side room should be reported the day it is found. The frozen pipe claims page shows how I build the heat record.

Old sanctuary, new code: two exclusions to check before the estimate

Many Illinois churches were built long before today's building codes. When part of one is rebuilt, the city can require work the old building never had.

What the insurer may sayWhat the form saysWhat I look for
"The code upgrade is not covered"The special form excludes the cost of complying with an ordinance or law that regulates construction or repair (exclusion B.1.a).An Ordinance or Law endorsement on the declarations page. When it is there, the code items go in the estimate as their own lines, with the inspector's requirement attached.
"The roof was just old"Wear and tear is excluded (B.2.d). Storm damage to an old roof is still storm damage.Fresh breaks, creases and missing pieces on the slopes that faced the storm, against even ageing on every slope. The hail damage claims page shows how hail is proved square by square.

The Maryland Insurance Administration's presentation on commercial policies for places of worship also lists building ordinance coverage and wear and tear among the items generally excluded unless bought separately.

The hall, the school and the rent while the church is closed

A damaged church often loses more than its building. The same regulator's guide names business income, "including rent and school tuition", as coverage a congregation has to buy for it to be there.

If your policy carries it, I add the lost income and the extra cost of holding services elsewhere to the claim. The business income claims page explains how the time and the amount are counted.

A school or preschool in the building

Tuition that stops while classrooms are repaired, if business income covers it.

The hall rented to groups

Rental income booked for the months the hall can't be used.

Services held somewhere else

Rent for a temporary space, moving costs and signage, under extra expense.

The parish house

Where the policy covers a clergy residence, living costs while it is uninhabitable.

Before the board votes on a public adjuster

The Illinois rules a council or a board of trustees should know, from the Illinois Department of Insurance.

  1. The contract is written and approved by the state. Illinois law requires a written contract approved by the Director of Insurance, with the fee stated in it.
  2. The church can change its mind. The contract can be cancelled by certified mail within 5 business days after it is signed.
  3. Nobody may solicit you at the wrong time. A public adjuster can't approach the church while the fire is still burning or the fire department is on site, or between 7 PM and 8 AM.
  4. The license can be checked by phone. Call the Department at (866) 445-5364. Mine is Illinois public adjuster license No. 19461872.
  5. The adjuster's loyalty is to the church alone. The Department's words are "objectivity and complete loyalty for your interests alone".

Source: Illinois Department of Insurance, commercial property public adjusters. For buildings that are not churches, see my commercial property claims page.

Portrait of Volodymyr Lukaniuk, public adjuster

Show me the church after the damage

Photos of the roof from the ground, the inside where the water or the damage is, the date it happened and the insurer's letter, if one came, are enough to start. I can meet the pastor, the council or the trustees at the church.

I also hold an Illinois roofing contractor license (No. 105.009193), a general contractor license and a HAAG inspector certification. I speak English, Ukrainian and Russian. More about my background is on the about page.

+1 224-481-2093 volodymyr@staterestoration.us

I answer seven days a week.

Our church was damaged

What happened, and which building or part of it was hit?

I read every message myself and reply about your claim only.

What pastors and trustees ask me

Who at the church should sign the contract with a public adjuster?

Whoever your bylaws let sign contracts for the property, usually the trustees, the council or the board. The Illinois contract is a form approved by the Director of Insurance, and the church can cancel it by certified mail within 5 business days after signing, so the board has time to read it after the vote.

The insurer sent its own adjuster. Why would a congregation need another one?

Their adjuster reports to the insurance company. I work only for the church: I inspect the roof and the steeple myself, write the repair scope as a licensed contractor, and read each limit and exclusion in your policy against what was damaged.

A statue fell during cleaning. Is it covered?

Under the common special form, a broken statue or marble piece is paid only when one of the listed causes broke it, such as wind, vandalism, a falling object or the weight of snow. A statue knocked over by accident is outside that clause. Your policy may carry a different form or a fine arts endorsement, and I check which one you have.

Can you tell us what the claim will pay?

Nobody can honestly promise an amount before the building is inspected and measured, and I don't. After the first visit I can show the board what is damaged, which part of the policy answers for it, and what proof each line of the estimate needs.

Do you work with parishes outside Chicago?

Yes. My public adjuster licenses cover Illinois and Indiana. I speak English, Ukrainian and Russian, so I can meet the priest, the pastor or the council in the language they use.